RSS | Archive | Random | E-mail

Find. Eat. Repeat.

We hope you've eaten already, because you can't eat pixels. Consider it a warning as you're bound to get Pavlovian while viewing endless pages of mouth-watering sandwiches. This is a quest to catalog everything that's delicious between 2 pieces of bread, or on top of 1 if it's an open-face.

The majority of the sandwiches consumed can primarily be found in and around the Chicagoland area; however, if and when we're in your town, rest assured we'll be on a 'wich Hunt.

Recent Posts

El Cubanito (Chicago, IL)
Panes Bread Cafe (Chicago, IL)
112 Eatery (Minneapolis, MN)
Bat 17 (Evanston, IL)
Bari Food's (Chicago, IL)
Bennison's Bakery (Evanston, IL)
Buffalo Joe's (Evanston, IL)

Eating Soon

Bon Bon Vietnamese
Zaleski & Horvath MarketCafe
Pastoral
Ba Le Bakery
Home of the Hoagy
Milk and Honey Cafe
Silver Palm
Lula Cafe
Hub 51
Perry's Deli
Goodwins
Lucky's Sandwich Company
Kim's Kitchen

Fan Favorite

If you know of a sammich that you feel should be up here, then describe it in 400 words or less, list the ingredients, take 2 pictures and email us, using the link at the top.

Once a month, we’ll be choosing the tastiest sounding submission to be featured as the "Fan Favorite." There might be a prize. Subway $5 GC or something equally useful. Maybe a t-shirt.

10 May 09
Steak SandwichEl Cubanito 2555 N Pulaski RdChicago, IL 60639 (Logan Square)
Alberto and Laritza Ramos have it locked down.  Moved to the States in ’07.  Opened the “postage stamp” size, 400 sq. ft. El Cubanito six months later and now, churn out 400+ Cubano sandwiches/day—in addition to the totals from the other 6 sandwiches on the menu.  Skills.  It needs to be mentioned that Alberto and Laritza are also the two nicest people you might ever meet.  Located on the 2500 block of Pulaski in the Avondale/Logan Square neighborhood in Chicago, El Cubanito is so small, it’ll have you circling the block saying, “It should be right here.  Where is it?  Is that it?  Google maps says it’s supposed to be right $!&%ing here.  Wait, what’s that!  Is that really it?  I think that’s it.”  When you step inside, there’ll be no question.  Immediately, the scent of grilled meats had this mystifying power over me.   It consumed my entire body.  It knew I was weak.  It took advantage of me.  It made me order two sandwiches.  I had to order the Cubano, no question.  But then I felt like I was being taunted by the crack and sizzle coming off the grill.  It spoke to me.  “Come on.  You’ll like me.  You can do it.  Just eat me.” Judging by the tickling sensation the grilled steak had on my nose, I had a feeling it would trump the transplanted Miami favorite.  The verdict?  Always follow your nose.  Don’t get it twisted—the Cubano is delicious.  Cuban bread, ham, roasted pork, yellow mustard, pickles, and butter.  Would I get it again?  Maybe.  I would get it if, for some god-awful reason, they didn’t have any steak sandwiches.  The Cubano is a distant second to the steak sandwich.  The Jane Brady.  The Scottie Pippen.  The thinly sliced and chopped steak wasn’t chewy, but wasn’t melt in your mouth.  It was; however perfectly seasoned.  The Swiss cheese: mild and semi-nutty.  The creamy and yellowy “house sauce”: a mixture of mustard, mayo and maybe oregano—just a guess.  It also included some thin slices of tomato and shredded lettuce.  A key component was the “Pik-Nik” style shoestring potatoes, adding some additional seasoning and unbeatable crunchy texture.  All of this pressed between the crispy Cuban-style bread using a Panini press type deal.  What happens during this pressing process is pretty significant, as all the ingredients form an alloy of flavorful deliciousness.  It’s ridiculous.  Go out and get some.  ‘wich Hunt approved.  Oh, and don’t pass up the café con leche—Muy riiiiiiiiiicoooo!
•    Cuban-style bread•    chopped steak •    queso suizo = swiss cheese•    lechuga = shredded lettuce•    tomate = tomato•    shoestring potatoes = genius ingredient•    house sauce = mustard, mayo and oregano.  A SWAG at best.
Notes on the pictures: (Top) South side exterior of El Cubanito.  There’s no signage in front.  If you’re heading northbound on Pulaski, it will be on the east side of the street.  Keep an eye out for this mural that faces the “parking lot.” (Below) Don’t be fooled by the slight of hand.  I ate the sandwiches in the comfort of my own home.  They don’t have any plates, much less a table, so don’t expect to eat at a nice wooden table with cute little green plates.  Oh, and this is only half of the Steak Sandwich.  The 1st half didn’t stand a chance.     

Steak Sandwich
El Cubanito
2555 N Pulaski Rd
Chicago, IL 60639 (Logan Square)

Alberto and Laritza Ramos have it locked down.  Moved to the States in ’07.  Opened the “postage stamp” size, 400 sq. ft. El Cubanito six months later and now, churn out 400+ Cubano sandwiches/day—in addition to the totals from the other 6 sandwiches on the menu.  Skills.  It needs to be mentioned that Alberto and Laritza are also the two nicest people you might ever meet.  Located on the 2500 block of Pulaski in the Avondale/Logan Square neighborhood in Chicago, El Cubanito is so small, it’ll have you circling the block saying, “It should be right here.  Where is it?  Is that it?  Google maps says it’s supposed to be right $!&%ing here.  Wait, what’s that!  Is that really it?  I think that’s it.” When you step inside, there’ll be no question. 

Immediately, the scent of grilled meats had this mystifying power over me.   It consumed my entire body.  It knew I was weak.  It took advantage of me.  It made me order two sandwiches.  I had to order the Cubano, no question.  But then I felt like I was being taunted by the crack and sizzle coming off the grill.  It spoke to me.  “Come on.  You’ll like me.  You can do it.  Just eat me.” Judging by the tickling sensation the grilled steak had on my nose, I had a feeling it would trump the transplanted Miami favorite.  The verdict?  Always follow your nose.  Don’t get it twisted—the Cubano is delicious.  Cuban bread, ham, roasted pork, yellow mustard, pickles, and butter.  Would I get it again?  Maybe.  I would get it if, for some god-awful reason, they didn’t have any steak sandwiches.  The Cubano is a distant second to the steak sandwich.  The Jane Brady.  The Scottie Pippen. 

The thinly sliced and chopped steak wasn’t chewy, but wasn’t melt in your mouth.  It was; however perfectly seasoned.  The Swiss cheese: mild and semi-nutty.  The creamy and yellowy “house sauce”: a mixture of mustard, mayo and maybe oregano—just a guess.  It also included some thin slices of tomato and shredded lettuce.  A key component was the “Pik-Nik” style shoestring potatoes, adding some additional seasoning and unbeatable crunchy texture.  All of this pressed between the crispy Cuban-style bread using a Panini press type deal.  What happens during this pressing process is pretty significant, as all the ingredients form an alloy of flavorful deliciousness.  It’s ridiculous.  Go out and get some.  ‘wich Hunt approved.  Oh, and don’t pass up the café con leche—Muy riiiiiiiiiicoooo!

•    Cuban-style bread
•    chopped steak
•    queso suizo = swiss cheese
•    lechuga = shredded lettuce
•    tomate = tomato
•    shoestring potatoes = genius ingredient
•    house sauce = mustard, mayo and oregano.  A SWAG at best.

Notes on the pictures: (Top) South side exterior of El Cubanito.  There’s no signage in front.  If you’re heading northbound on Pulaski, it will be on the east side of the street.  Keep an eye out for this mural that faces the “parking lot.” (Below) Don’t be fooled by the slight of hand.  I ate the sandwiches in the comfort of my own home.  They don’t have any plates, much less a table, so don’t expect to eat at a nice wooden table with cute little green plates.  Oh, and this is only half of the Steak Sandwich.  The 1st half didn’t stand a chance.     

4 May 09
Oaxacan Pork Panes Bread Cafe 3002 N Sheffield Ave. Chicago, IL 60657 (Lakeview)
Swine Flu is all the rage these days, so much that people are doing some pretty outlandish things.  I can maybe understand a precautionary hand sanitizer purchase.  Or maybe even a paranoid glance behind your newspaper at the woman with the whooping cough, sitting across from you on the bus, who for some reason can’t just cover her mouth.  Seriously lady, just cover your mouth.  I can even kinda, sorta understand wearing a mask while traveling through O’Hare.   Kinda.  Sorta.  But I can’t understand the type who refuse to eat pork.  That’s just stupid.  You know what I have to say to those people?  “You’re stupid.”  Harsh?  Not if you read Oaxacan Pork and say, “Uh oh.  It’s pork and it has a Spanish sounding word in front of it.  That’s double jeopardy.  I better stay away.  I might get the super-duper strain.” You know, maybe I’m stupid.  Maybe there is some way I could get the sniffles and a mildly high fever after eating this sandwich.  Doesn’t matter.  It’s so worth it.  Panes is a Mexican sandwich café that kinda flies under the radar.  I say that because I lived within a mile of the place and learned about it years after the fact (propers to Jesus for the introduction).  They’ve got “regular” type sandwiches that I’ve never tried (BLTs, Clubs, etc.) and other sandwiches with names and flavors that are more inline with Mexican fare.  The Pollo Diablo is pretty good, but the Oaxacan Pork is where it’s at.  Properly proportioned in a way that you get all the sweet and savory flavors from the caramelized onions, roasted red pepper, spicy mayo and tender pork loin all in one spectacular bite.  Panes (pronounced “pa-ness,” with a short “a” not “pains” for you Swine Flu fearing folk), also makes their own bread daily, which adds to the freshness and quality of the sandwich.  The bread used in the Oaxacan is like a French type grain bread.  Nice, crunchy exterior and chewy soft interior perfect for absorbing all the juicy wonderfulness.  Oh, and it comes with chips.  It can take a long time to get your food; although, I do get impatient because I know the feeling of eating it will be like cracking open a piñata and finding dozens of Oaxacan Pork sandwiches.  If your confused, that feeling is joy.  Anyways, I often equate longer waits with fresher food, so it’s really not all that bad.  They also have a display case of sweets that I’ve heard are good, but never tried.  I struggle with saying that I would be satisfied if I died from swine flu after eating it.  I really think I might be alright with that.•    grain French bread•    pork loin•    caramelized onions•    roasted red peppers•    spicy mayo
Note: Names have been changed to help preserve anonymity.

Oaxacan Pork
Panes Bread Cafe
3002 N Sheffield Ave.
Chicago, IL 60657 (Lakeview)

Swine Flu is all the rage these days, so much that people are doing some pretty outlandish things.  I can maybe understand a precautionary hand sanitizer purchase.  Or maybe even a paranoid glance behind your newspaper at the woman with the whooping cough, sitting across from you on the bus, who for some reason can’t just cover her mouth.  Seriously lady, just cover your mouth.  I can even kinda, sorta understand wearing a mask while traveling through O’Hare.   Kinda.  Sorta.  But I can’t understand the type who refuse to eat pork.  That’s just stupid.  You know what I have to say to those people?  “You’re stupid.”  Harsh?  Not if you read Oaxacan Pork and say, “Uh oh.  It’s pork and it has a Spanish sounding word in front of it.  That’s double jeopardy.  I better stay away.  I might get the super-duper strain.” You know, maybe I’m stupid.  Maybe there is some way I could get the sniffles and a mildly high fever after eating this sandwich.  Doesn’t matter.  It’s so worth it. 

Panes is a Mexican sandwich café that kinda flies under the radar.  I say that because I lived within a mile of the place and learned about it years after the fact (propers to Jesus for the introduction).  They’ve got “regular” type sandwiches that I’ve never tried (BLTs, Clubs, etc.) and other sandwiches with names and flavors that are more inline with Mexican fare.  The Pollo Diablo is pretty good, but the Oaxacan Pork is where it’s at.  Properly proportioned in a way that you get all the sweet and savory flavors from the caramelized onions, roasted red pepper, spicy mayo and tender pork loin all in one spectacular bite.  Panes (pronounced “pa-ness,” with a short “a” not “pains” for you Swine Flu fearing folk), also makes their own bread daily, which adds to the freshness and quality of the sandwich.  The bread used in the Oaxacan is like a French type grain bread.  Nice, crunchy exterior and chewy soft interior perfect for absorbing all the juicy wonderfulness.  Oh, and it comes with chips.  It can take a long time to get your food; although, I do get impatient because I know the feeling of eating it will be like cracking open a piñata and finding dozens of Oaxacan Pork sandwiches.  If your confused, that feeling is joy.  Anyways, I often equate longer waits with fresher food, so it’s really not all that bad.  They also have a display case of sweets that I’ve heard are good, but never tried.  I struggle with saying that I would be satisfied if I died from swine flu after eating it.  I really think I might be alright with that.

•    grain French bread
•    pork loin
•    caramelized onions
•    roasted red peppers
•    spicy mayo

Note: Names have been changed to help preserve anonymity.

Oaxacan Pork from Panes